FTX might not have been the only crypto exchange using customer money for other things (2024)

Happy Friday eve, Opening Bell crew. Senior reporter Phil Rosen here.

As if the universe knew that I hadn't written a crypto newsletter in some time, here we go: Binance, the world's largest crypto exchange, has been under some scrutiny this week.

And the reasoning reminds me of what happened in the lead-up to the collapse of Sam Bankman-Fried's FTX, an event many consider the Lehman Brothers of crypto.

If this was forwarded to you, sign up here. Download Insider's app here.

Eric PIERMONT / AFP) (Photo by ERIC PIERMONT/AFP via Getty Images

1. With the initial reaction to FTX largely in the rearview mirror, crypto chatter in 2023 has mostly centered on the volatility seen across various tokens.

Advertisem*nt

Bitcoin, the world's most popular token, jumped roughly 40% in January, though it made a measly 1% gain in February. Ether, meanwhile, climbed 31% in January, but also had a muted month following.

Yet digital asset happenings have become intriguing once again after Forbes reported this week that Binance used customer funds for its own purposes, in a similar way that FTX did.

The world's largest crypto exchange reportedly transferred nearly $1.8 billion in stablecoin collateral to hedge funds, the report said. Forbes concluded that over $1 billion of customer assets were left exposed and were not backed one-to-one as the exchange had previously stated.

Here's what a spokesperson from the exchange told Insider:

Advertisem*nt

"Binance does not, and has never, invested or otherwise deployed user assets without consent under the terms of specific product. Binance holds all of its clients' assets in segregated accounts which are identified separately from any accounts used to hold assets belonging to Binance."

Any move by Binance to shuffle customer money around isn't exactly illegal, but the risks are apparent in the wake of the FTX disaster, part of which involved the exchange using customer money for making big bets via its affiliated trading arm.

Meanwhile, the Financial Times reported Wednesday that Binance's stablecoin, BUSD, suffered $6 billion in outflows in the month of February. It's the world's third largest stablecoin, and it's supposed to be pegged to the US dollar — but that one-to-one ratio is beginning to show signs of crumbling.

During a Twitter Spaces talk last month, chief executive Changpeng Zhao downplayed the ties between the exchange and its branded token.

Advertisem*nt

"BUSD is not issued by Binance," he said. "We have an agreement to let [Paxos] use our brand, but that's not something that we created."

All this comes after another report said Binance had secret access to a bank account belonging to its ostensibly independent US partner.

That account, Reuters reported, was used to send $400 million to a trading firm managed by Zhao.

How confident are you in the cryptocurrency market and digital asset sector? Tweet me (@philrosenn) or email me (prosen@businessinsider.com) to let me know.

In other news:

Advertisem*nt

2.US stock futures fall early Thursday and government bonds sell off, suggesting investors are bracing for a longer period of higher interest rates. Meanwhile, Tesla shares slide after Elon Musk falls short on detail at the much-anticipated investor day. Here are the latest market moves.

3. Earnings on deck: Broadcom, Costco, and Toronto-Dominion Bank, all reporting.

4. The chief investment strategist at a $540 billion firm thinks the stock market could have already bottomed for the year. Even as many experts are screaming "sell" over recent weeks, Wes Crill believes there's reason for optimism. Here's what he's most bullish on for 2023 and beyond.

5. Russia's ruble has crashed 20% as wartime costs pile up and energy revenues decline. The currency has been trading at roughly 75 rubles per dollar, the lowest mark in 10 months. In an effort to close budget deficits, Moscow has been selling its reserves of Chinese yuan.

Advertisem*nt

6. Mortgage loan applications just hit their lowest level in 28 years. Data from the Mortgage Bankers Association released Wednesday showed housing demand is still getting beat down by higher rate expectations. Zillow and Redfin analysts told Insider they expect the US housing slump to deepen as the year progresses.

7. Artificial intelligence is on the brink of an "iPhone moment." Bank of America strategists see nascent technology adding trillions of dollars to the global economy. Given AI's commercial potential and ability to democratize data, they predict it will "revolutionize everything."

8. Navigating this year's stock market is going to be tricky. But this CIO of a top wealth-management firm shared six tips for investors looking to come out on top. Here's what you want to know.

9. Five market-beating fund managers gave their takes on how to take advantage of a comeback rally for foreign stocks. International stocks have outperformed in the last five months — and these are the smartest ways to profit from a long-term rally for once-forgotten names.

Advertisem*nt

Markets Insider

10. Novavax stock plunged after the COVID-19 vaccine maker said it had "substantial doubt" about its ability to stay in business. There's uncertainty over its revenue moving forward, and the biotech firm saw fourth-quarter losses twice as deep as expected. Get the full details.

Curated by Phil Rosen in New York. Feedback or tips? Tweet @philrosenn or email prosen@businessinsider.com.

Edited by Max Adams (@maxradams) in New York and Hallam Bullock (@hallam_bullock) in London.

FTX might not have been the only crypto exchange using customer money for other things (2024)

FAQs

Did FTX use customer money? ›

FTX: new technology, old-fashioned embezzlement

At trial, the court heard from an accounting expert who said that $11.3bn in customer funds were supposed to be held at Alameda Research, FTX's hedge fund arm.

Will FTX customers get their money back? ›

FTX says that nearly all of its customers will receive the money back that they are owed, two years after the cryptocurrency exchange imploded, and some will get more than that. FTX said in a court filing late Tuesday that it owes about $11.2 billion to its creditors.

Was FTX a cryptocurrency exchange? ›

FTX was one of the largest digital currency exchange platforms for buying and selling cryptocurrencies. As more people invested in cryptocurrencies, they turned to these platforms because they provided a digital wallet to store cryptocurrencies directly in a personal account.

How much money did FTX steal? ›

Kaplan found that FTX customers lost $8 billion, FTX's equity investors lost $1.7 billion, and that lenders to the Alameda Research hedge fund Bankman-Fried founded lost $1.3 billion. He imposed an $11 billion forfeiture order and authorized the government to repay victims with seized assets.

Where did FTX get its money? ›

On September 26, 2022, FTX.US won its bid at auction for the digital assets of bankrupt crypto brokerage Voyager Digital. The value of the deal was approximately $1.42 billion, including $1.31 billion in Voyager-held cryptocurrency and $111 million in additional consideration.

How much does FTX owe customers? ›

On May 7, the company said it expects to have as much as $16.3 billion once it's done selling assets, far more than the approximately $11 billion owed to customers and other private-sector creditors, leaving most of them in line to get 118% of what they had in their FTX accounts.

What led to the collapse of FTX? ›

FTX and FTX.US crashed due to a lack of liquidity and mismanagement of funds, followed by a large volume of withdrawals from rattled investors. The value of FTT plummeted, taking other coins down with it including Ethereum and Bitcoin, which reached a two-year low on Nov. 9, 2022.

Who lost money in FTX? ›

Kevin Zhao, who ran a hedge fund called Galois Capital, lost control of $40 million of his fund's assets after they were frozen on FTX. At the time, executives who took over FTX warned that most customers' money was “lost or stolen.” Zhao decided it wasn't worth waiting around to see how much he would get back.

What cryptos does FTX own? ›

FTX Top 10 Holdings
AssetHoldings ($M)% of Circulating Supply
BTC5600.11%
ETH1920.09%
APT13710.38%
USDT1200.14%
6 more rows
Dec 4, 2023

How much money went missing from FTX? ›

The exchange's founder Sam Bankman-Fried secretly transferred $10 billion of customer funds from FTX to Bankman-Fried's trading company Alameda Research, the people told Reuters. A large portion of that total has since disappeared, they said. One source put the missing amount at about $1.7 billion.

What does FTX stand for? ›

FTX, which stands for 'Futures Exchange', was found complicit in a nefarious scandal following the actions of Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF), the CEO. Over the past decade, the company experienced significant growth, solidifying its position as one of the leading digital currency exchange platforms.

What happened to the owner of FTX? ›

Sam Bankman-Fried, disgraced co-founder of the now-defunct cryptocurrency exchange FTX, was sentenced to 25 years in prison on Thursday for his part in defrauding customers of billions of dollars.

What did FTX offer to customers? ›

FTX supported trading for popular cryptocurrencies, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and spot, derivatives, and leveraged markets. Although FTX stock was never available for public trading, the exchange did issue a token (FTT) that traded on cryptocurrency markets.

What happens to people who had money in FTX? ›

ICYMI: FTX, the crypto exchange that has become a byword for fraud and a black eye on the face of the entire digital asset industry, said that virtually all of the people who had money frozen on the platform will get their money back, plus interest. That is an extraordinary outcome.

Can people get their money out of FTX? ›

According to a news release filed Tuesday by FTX, which is going through reorganization, 98% of FTX creditors, including individual investors, who had $50,000 or less with the company will receive the funds they lost, in cash, within 60 days of a reorganization plan going into effect.

What are customer funds? ›

More Definitions of Customer Funds

Customer Funds means any cash or cash equivalents received by, or on behalf of, an Acquired Company for the purpose of satisfying the obligations of any customer of an Acquired Company; including any such amounts shown on the Most Recent Financial Statements.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 5832

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.