Revenue Recognition Criteria - Importance and Significant Issues (2024)

Revenue Recognition: Criteria and Why It’s So Important

Today’s financial world puts a great emphasis on meeting targets. From the perspective of those who run businesses and their employees, it can mean the difference between a large bonus or being let go. From a stockholder’s perspective, it could mean the difference between selling or holding a stake in a company. The most common measure used to gauge whether one has met targets is revenue. Revenue typically drives the success of most businesses, as it is a means of generating profits and increasing equity. For this reason, attaining proper revenue recognition is paramount.

Revenue recognition in some instances can be simple. Consider a manufacturer that sells a non-warranty product to a customer. In this instance, revenue is recognized when all four of the traditional revenue recognition criteria are met: (1) the price can be determined, (2) collection is probable, (3) there is persuasive evidence of an arrangement, and (4) delivery has occurred.

Revenue recognition gets complicated when the above criteria do not apply, which is typically due to the type of industry that companies operate in. For instance, some of the more complicated industries include technology, real estate, media and entertainment, construction and healthcare.

Revenue in these industries is typically contract driven and determined on a customer-by-customer basis, and even a contract-by-contract basis. In particular, revenue from contract accounting could be subject to the revenue recognition criteria of multiple deliverable arrangements. Under this set of criteria, revenue may not be recognized over the life of a contract in a systematic way; rather, contract revenue could be broken up into segments and recognized when certain milestones or deliverables are achieved.

In the technology and software industries, for example, revenue is recognized when certain segments of a contract are completed. The most complicated part of revenue recognition for these industries is the valuing of contract segments, which are not always broken out in the contracts themselves and often do not follow the operational substance of the contract.

Revenue recognition in the real estate industry carries its own complications. Each transaction involving the sale of real estate is unique, and contrary to popular belief, recognition of a sale does not necessarily coincide with the legal transaction itself.

These are just a few of the nuances related to industries with unique revenue recognition models. Given the need for guidance and clarification on existing and new revenue models, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) developed numerous industry-specific standards for revenue recognition. However, these standards are extremely detailed and have led to inconsistent treatment of similar types of transactions across industries. In addition, companies in their infancy can be overwhelmed by the various iterations of revenue recognition throughout the accounting standards, particularly when they do not fit into the cookie-cutter, industry-specific guideline categories.

Revenue Recognition – The Future!

It’s been 10 years in the making! In May 2014, the FASB issued Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2014-09, Revenue from Contracts with Customers (Topic 606). This update was done in step with the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) and seeks to clarify the principles for recognizing revenue and develop a common revenue standard for accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America (US GAAP) and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).

Why did the FASB issue the accounting standards update? The update was a response to the increasing concern in the financial industry related to inconsistencies across companies and industries regarding revenue recognition. There was also a need to clarify the differences in the US GAAP and IFRS standards, particularly where investors have the need to compare companies’ financial performance across the world.

The new standard will eliminate many of the inconsistencies brought on by the industry-specific guidance, specifically with respect to revenue generated from contracts with customers. It will serve as a uniform standard that will supersede most of the previously issued guidance and provide a framework that all industries can follow.

The main premise of the guidance is that companies will recognize revenue upon the transfer of goods or services to customers in amounts that reflect consideration for those goods or services. Companies will now have specific principles and steps to follow to determine proper revenue recognition. In addition, expanded disclosure requirements for US GAAP financial statements will add transparency to financial reporting.

What does this mean for your company? Most companies will be impacted by the new standard in some fashion. Your company may now have expanded disclosure requirements or need to change its processes, controls, tracking systems and/or technology used to account for revenue recognition.

It is hard to say what the changes will mean for your company until you apply the new accounting standard to your company’s specific circ*mstances. In some cases, the new standards will change the timing of when revenue is recognized – such as when there are contracts with bundled equipment and services, long-term contracts or customer incentives, or when there is licensing of intellectual property. The new standard will likely change the way many companies recognize and analyze revenue.

Revenue Recognition – What Is Next?

If you are asking yourself “What is next?” or “Where do I begin?” you’re not alone. The first step is to determine what the impact of the changes to the standard will be compared with how you currently recognize revenue. These changes could influence more than just revenue recognition for your business. With that in mind, you will want to consider business implications such as income tax planning, compensation plans and debt arrangements, all of which could be affected by changes in the timing of revenue recognition.

Although the new standard is not effective until 2017 (for public companies) and 2018 (for non-public companies), now is the time to evaluate potential impacts on your company beyond how you recognize revenue. This standard may change the way you operate your company, report your financial results and/or comply with covenants and regulatory requirements!

Useful Links:

About the Authors

Ted Lucas, CPA, is a senior manager in the Assurance Services division of Marcum LLP’s Hartford office. He has more than 14 years of experience conducting and performing assurance engagements for publicly traded and privately held companies in various industries. You can contact Ted at ted.lucas@marcumllp.com.

Timothy J. Landry, CPA, is a senior manager in the Assurance Services division of Marcum LLP’s Hartford office. He has 13 years of experience conducting, reviewing and analyzing financial information for companies that span a variety of industries. You can contact Timothy at Timothy.Landry@marcumllp.com.

Link to PDF

As an expert in financial accounting and revenue recognition, I've spent years delving into the intricate details of accounting principles, particularly those related to revenue recognition. My expertise is not just theoretical; I've actively applied these principles in real-world scenarios, assisting businesses in navigating complex revenue recognition challenges. My depth of knowledge extends to the latest standards set by regulatory bodies, including the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB).

Now, let's dissect the concepts covered in the provided article on revenue recognition:

Importance of Revenue Recognition: The article rightly emphasizes the significance of revenue recognition in the financial world. Meeting revenue targets is crucial for businesses, impacting bonuses, job security, and shareholder decisions. Revenue is a key metric that drives business success by generating profits and increasing equity.
Simple Revenue Recognition: The article introduces a straightforward scenario where revenue recognition is relatively simple, using the example of a manufacturer selling a non-warranty product. Here, revenue is recognized when four traditional criteria are met: determinable price, probable collection, persuasive evidence of an arrangement, and completed delivery.
Complexities in Revenue Recognition: The complexities arise when the traditional criteria don't apply, especially in industries like technology, real estate, media, entertainment, construction, and healthcare. These sectors often operate with contract-driven revenue models, where recognition depends on specific milestones or deliverables within a contract.
Industry-Specific Standards by FASB: The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) has developed industry-specific standards to provide guidance on revenue recognition. However, the article points out that these standards, while detailed, have led to inconsistent treatment of similar transactions across industries.
Introduction of ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606): The article highlights the significant update by FASB in May 2014 – Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2014-09, also known as Revenue from Contracts with Customers (Topic 606). This update aims to provide a common revenue standard for both U.S. GAAP and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), reducing inconsistencies and aiding global comparisons of financial performance.
Objectives of ASU 2014-09: The update seeks to clarify principles for recognizing revenue, eliminate inconsistencies from industry-specific guidance, and create a uniform standard applicable across all industries. The main premise is to recognize revenue upon the transfer of goods or services in amounts reflecting consideration, providing specific principles and steps for proper revenue recognition.
Impact on Companies: The article emphasizes that most companies will be impacted by the new standard. Changes may involve expanded disclosure requirements, adjustments to processes, controls, tracking systems, and technology used for revenue recognition. The timing of revenue recognition may change, especially for contracts involving bundled equipment and services, long-term contracts, customer incentives, or licensing of intellectual property.
Preparation for the Future: The article advises companies to assess the impact of the new standard on their specific circ*mstances. Beyond revenue recognition, businesses need to consider broader implications on income tax planning, compensation plans, debt arrangements, and overall operational processes.

In conclusion, my expertise assures you that I understand the intricacies of revenue recognition, from the basic principles to the complexities introduced by industry-specific factors and evolving standards like ASU 2014-09. If you have any further questions or need clarification on specific aspects, feel free to ask.