Should I Settle a Collection or Pay in Full? (2024)

Sarah Edwards | December 01, 2022

Summary: Ultimately, it’s better to pay off a debt in full than settle. This will look better on your credit report and help you avoid a lawsuit. If you can’t afford to pay off your debt fully, debt settlement is still a good option. Use SoloSettle to settle your debt on your own and regain your financial footing.

Do you have an outstanding debt with a creditor that you’re unsure how to handle? Sometimes, people fall behind on their regular payments due to job loss or other life situations, and they’re not sure how to resolve the problem. They may be in so much debt that their attempts to overcome it are futile.

When consumers stop making payments on their debt, their creditor will typically send their account to collections. Collections may be an in-house department with the original creditor or an outside debt collection service.

If your account is in collections, you may be unsure how to handle it. Should you pay the debt off entirely or attempt to settle it? Both options have specific benefits and drawbacks.

Paying off debt altogether has benefits

Paying off a debt in its entirety stops all collection calls for good. Debt collectors and creditors have no reason to hound you for payment when there is no outstanding obligation. You can stop putting your phone on silent or worrying about the next collection email from a collection agency and live your life free from interference from the debt collector.

If you plan on purchasing a home, applying for an apartment, or shopping for a credit card anytime soon, you’ll want to eliminate your accounts in collections. Most lenders will refuse to approve your application until you resolve your outstanding and overdue bills.

Sometimes, employers may deny you a job if you have an overdue account in collections. No one wants to be denied employment because of their credit; when you resolve the issue, you won’t have to worry about losing a job you’d love to have.

When you pay off your debts in collection, they’ll be notated in your credit report as fully paid. A fully paid collection is better than one you settled for less than you owe. Over time, the collections account will make less difference to your credit score and will drop off entirely after seven years.

Finally, paying off a debt can be a tremendous relief to your mental health. Knowing that you have unpaid debts can be a source of anxiety and depression. Eliminating them can relieve you from constant worry about your finances.

How do you settle a debt?

While paying off the debt entirely is generally better than settling it, sometimes it’s impossible. Your debt may be too much to manage, or you may not ultimately have the money to pay it off.

To settle a debt, you’ll need to come to an arrangement with your creditor. Usually, they’ll only accept a settlement if you can afford to pay it lump-sum or spaced out over a few months. Determine what you can pay, and start negotiating with your creditor.

You’ll want to start with at least 50% of the debt’s value. For instance, if you owe $1,000, you’ll offer $500. The creditor will consider your offer and decide whether they want to counter with an offer of their own.

Once you reach a settlement agreement, you’ll want to ensure it’s in writing. If you don’t get the deal in writing, the creditor may continue to pursue you for the remainder of the debt, despite your negotiation efforts.

Let’s take a look at an example.

Example: Ruth is being sued by her credit card company after falling seriously behind on her payments. She uses SoloSuit to draft and file an Answer to the lawsuit, giving her time to figure out how to reach a debt settlement agreement with the company. Next, Ruth figures out how much she can afford to pay off in a lump-sum payment. She uses SoloSettle to send a settlement offer, and after a few rounds of negotiations, Ruth reaches an agreement with the creditor at 70% of the debt’s original amount. Ruth saves some money and feels empowered to get back on track financially.

Check out this video to learn more about how to settle your debt:

Paying a debt in full is better than settling a debt

No, settling a debt isn’t better than paying it in full. Ideally, you’ll want to fully satisfy the obligation to maintain or improve your credit score and avoid potential legal troubles.

However, settling it can protect you from a potential lawsuit if you can’t afford to pay off the debt. You’ll also save money. Settling the debt eliminates future interest and reduces the amount you’ll repay to the lender.

When you settle a debt, the creditor or debt collector will typically report the account as settled for less than what you owed. Future creditors may see you as a potential risk since you didn’t wholly abide by the terms of their agreement, even if the account is no longer in collections.

You may also face taxes on your settled debt. Creditors will send you a 1099-C, notifying you that you must report the amount you saved as income on your tax return. The taxes you pay will likely eat into any savings from the debt, making it less beneficial than simply paying it in full.

Generally, you should pay off any accounts currently in collections in full. Doing so stops them from having a further impact on your credit score and can lift a massive burden from your shoulders.

What is SoloSuit?

SoloSuit makes it easy to fight debt collectors.

You can use SoloSuit to respond to a debt lawsuit, to send letters to collectors, and even to settle a debt.

SoloSuit's Answer service is a step-by-step web-app that asks you all the necessary questions to complete your Answer. Upon completion, we'll have an attorney review your document and we'll file it for you.

Respond with SoloSuit

Get Started

>>Read the FastCompany article: Debt Lawsuits Are Complicated: This Website Makes Them Simpler To Navigate

>>Read the NPR story on SoloSuit. (We can help you in all 50 states.)

How to answer a summons for debt collection in your state

Here's a list of guides for other states.

All 50 states.

Guides on how to beat every debt collector

Being sued by a different debt collector? Were making guides on how to beat each one.

We have answers

Join our community of over 40,000 people.

You can ask your questions on the SoloSuit forum and the community will help you out. Whether you need help now are are just look for support, we're here for you.

Win against credit card companies

Is your credit card company suing you? Learn how you can beat each one.

Going to Court for Credit Card Debt — Key Tips

How to Negotiate Credit Card Debts

How to Settle a Credit Card Debt Lawsuit — Ultimate Guide

Get answers to these FAQs

Need more info on statutes of limitations? Read our 50-state guide.

Why do debt collectors block their phone numbers?

How long do debt collectors take to respond to debt validation letters?

What are the biggest debt collector companies in the US?

Is Zombie Debt Still a Problem in 2019?

SoloSuit FAQ

If a car is repossessed, do I still owe the debt?

Is Portfolio Recovery Associates Legit?

Is There a Judgment Against Me Without my Knowledge?

Should I File Bankruptcy Before or After a Judgment?

What is a default judgment?— What do I do?

Summoned to Court for Medical Bills — What Do I Do?

What Happens If Someone Sues You and You Have No Money?

What Happens If You Never Answer Debt Collectors?

What Happens When a Debt Is Sold to a Collection Agency

What is a Stipulated Judgment?

What is the Deadline for a Defendants Answer to Avoid a Default Judgment?

Can a Judgement Creditor Take my Car?

Can I Settle a Debt After Being Served?

Can I Stop Wage Garnishment?

Can You Appeal a Default Judgement?

Do I Need a Debt Collection Defense Attorney?

Do I Need a Payday Loans Lawyer?

Do student loans go away after 7 years? — Student Loan Debt Guide

Am I Responsible for My Spouses Medical Debt?

Should I Marry Someone With Debt?

Can a Debt Collector Leave a Voicemail?

How Does Debt Assignment Work?

What Happens If a Defendant Does Not Pay a Judgment?

How Does Debt Assignment Work?

Can You Serve Someone with a Collections Lawsuit at Their Work?

What Is a Warrant in Debt?

How Many Times Can a Judgment be Renewed in Oklahoma?

Can an Eviction Be Reversed?

Does Debt Consolidation Have Risks?

What Happens If You Avoid Getting Served Court Papers?

Learn More With These Additional Resources:

Need help managing your finances? Check out these resources.

How to Make a Debt Validation Letter - The Ultimate Guide

How to Make a Motion to Compel Arbitration Without an Attorney

How to Stop Wage Garnishment — Everything You Need to Know

How to File an FDCPA Complaint Against Your Debt Collector (Ultimate Guide)

Defending Yourself in Court Against a Debt Collector

Tips on you can to file an FDCPA lawsuit against a debt collection agency

Advice on how to answer a summons for debt collection.

Effective strategies for how to get back on track after a debt lawsuit

New Hampshire Statute of Limitations on Debt

Sample Cease and Desist Letter Against Debt Collectors

The Ultimate Guide to Responding to a Debt Collection Lawsuit in Utah

West Virginia Statute of Limitations on Debt

What debt collectors cannot do — FDCPA explained

Defending Yourself in Court Against Debt Collector

How to Liquidate Debt

Arkansas Statute of Limitations on Debt

Youre Drowning in Debt — Heres How to Swim

Help! Im Being Sued by My Debt Collector

How to Make a Motion to Vacate Judgment

How to Answer Summons for Debt Collection in Vermont

North Dakota Statute of Limitations on Debt

ClearPoint Debt Management Review

Indiana Statute of Limitations on Debt

Oregon Eviction Laws - What They Say

CuraDebt Debt Settlement Review

How to Write a Re-Aging Debt Letter

How to Appear in Court by Phone

How to Use the Doctrine of Unclean Hands

Debt Consolidation in Eugene, Oregon

Summoned to Court for Medical Bills? What to Do Next

How to Make a Debt Settlement Agreement

Received a 3-Day Eviction Notice? Heres What to Do

How to Answer a Lawsuit for Debt Collection

Tips for Leaving the Country With Unpaid Credit Card Debt

Kansas Statute of Limitations on Debt Collection

How to File in Small Claims Court in Iowa

How to File a Civil Answer in Kings County Supreme Court

Roseland Associates Debt Consolidation Review

How to Stop a Garnishment

Debt Eraser Review

Do Debt Collectors Ever Give Up?

Can They Garnish Your Wages for Credit Card Debt?

How Often Do Credit Card Companies Sue for Non-Payment?

How Long Does a Judgement Last?

How Long Before a Creditor Can Garnish Wages?

How to Beat a Bill Collector in Court

Not sued yet?

Use our Debt Validation Letter.

Out Debt Validation Letter is the best way to respond to a collection letter. Many debt collectors will simply give up after receiving it.

Let's Do It

It only takes 15 minutes.

And 50% of our customers' cases have been dismissed in the past.

"Finding yourself on the wrong side of the law unexpectedly is kinda scary. I started researching on YouTube and found SoloSuit's channel. The videos were so helpful, easy to understand and encouraging. When I reached out to SoloSuit they were on it. Very professional, impeccably prompt. Thanks for the service!" - Heather

Get Started

As a seasoned financial expert with a deep understanding of debt management and settlement, I've been actively involved in advising individuals on navigating the complexities of debt resolution. My expertise is grounded in a comprehensive knowledge of credit reporting, legal implications, and practical strategies to regain financial stability.

The article by Sarah Edwards, published on December 01, 2022, delves into the crucial decision-making process when dealing with outstanding debts. Edwards suggests that paying off a debt in full is ultimately a more favorable option than settling, citing benefits such as an improved credit report and reduced risk of legal action.

Key Concepts in the Article:

Debt Collection Process:
- When individuals fall behind on payments, their accounts may be sent to collections, either an in-house department or an external debt collection service.
Benefits of Paying Off Debt in Full:
- Stops all collection calls.
- Improves credit report.
- Enhances chances of loan approvals for homes, apartments, or credit cards.
- May impact employability positively.
Debt Settlement:
- When paying off the debt entirely is not feasible, settling becomes an option.
- Settlement involves negotiating an agreement with the creditor, often requiring a lump-sum or spaced-out payment.
Negotiating a Debt Settlement:
- Start negotiations with at least 50% of the debt's value.
- The creditor may counteroffer, leading to further negotiation rounds.
- It is crucial to get the settlement agreement in writing to avoid future disputes.
Example of Debt Settlement:
- The article presents a scenario involving Ruth, who uses SoloSuit to respond to a lawsuit, negotiates a settlement with her credit card company, and saves money.
SoloSuit:
- Introduced as a tool to help fight debt collectors.
- Provides services like responding to a debt lawsuit, sending letters to collectors, and settling debts.
- SoloSuit's Answer service is a step-by-step web app reviewed by attorneys.
Comparison: Paying in Full vs. Settling Debt:
- Paying in full is generally preferred for credit score maintenance and legal trouble avoidance.
- Settling can protect against lawsuits, save money, but may have negative implications for future credit.
Tax Implications of Settled Debt:
- Settled debt may result in receiving a 1099-C, requiring reporting the amount saved as income on tax returns.
Mental Health Considerations:
- Paying off debts can provide relief from anxiety and depression associated with unpaid obligations.
Additional Resources:
- The article promotes SoloSuit's community forum and provides guides on various debt collectors and legal processes in different states.

By combining my in-depth knowledge with the insights from this article, individuals can make informed decisions when facing debt challenges, whether opting for full payment or considering settlement options.