Should You Replace or Rekey Locks? (2024)

Get quotes from up to 3

pros

!

Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.

Your lock is your first line of defense when it comes to your home's security. Whether you just moved into a new house or have been in your home for a decade, it may be time for a professional locksmith to rekey or change your locks. But what’s the difference, and which route should you take?

When to Rekey Your Locks

Rekeying is a quick way to upgrade your current locks, depending on the type of deadbolt you have. If you have a quality lock that works well, rekeying it is your best option.

Some locksmiths may tell you that you should change your locks. But in many cases, you can just rekey them, which means changing the existing lock system so a new key operates it. A locksmith simply replaces the tumblers and pins to create a lock that can be opened with a brand-new key. The locksmith can also check on the lock’s condition and add lubrication to maintain your lock. Are you planning to rekey your locks? You’re likely stuck in one of the following situations.

Locks That Require Multiple Keys

Lighten the load on your keychain and eliminate confusion by rekeying every lock to the same key. To do this, locks throughout your home need to be the same brand or have the same type of keyholes to rekey. Before calling your locksmith, you can test this out by trying your keys in the locks you want rekeyed to see if they have the same keyholes. If they slide right in, you’re good to rekey.

Moving

After moving into a new home, you don’t know who else has a key to your door. Ensure that only you and your family have access to your new home by having your doors rekeyed.

Lost Key

You lost a key, and you’re worried someone may find it and use it to access your home. If that’s the case, it’s best to start fresh with a new set of keys.

Concierge Services Change

You are changing concierge services, like housekeepers, babysitters, or pet sitters, who have a copy of your house key.

Rekeying Lock Cost

When rekeying your locks, you pay primarily for the labor, not the parts, which makes it more affordable than changing out the lock completely. The cost of rekeying can range from $50 to $100 on average.

Make sure you have the old key. The locksmith can always pick your lock, but that will cost extra.

Can You Rekey a Home Yourself?

If you’re in a pinch, it’s relatively easy to rekey your door locks on your own. The easiest method is to purchase a rekey kit, including pins, keys, and various other tools. Rekey kits typically cost $10 to $25 each.

However, don’t buy the first rekey kit you find on the hardware store shelf. Ensure that you buy a rekey kit from the same manufacturer as your home’s locks.

Changing Your Locks

Should You Replace or Rekey Locks? (1)

Photo: inga / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

When you change your locks, a local locksmith installs an entirely new lock with a new key. This service is pricier than having your locks rekeyed, as you are paying for not just the labor of the locksmith, but also the hardware of a whole new locking system. Changing your locks costs around $75 per hour.

Can You Change Locks by Yourself?

It’s possible to change locks on your own, but only under the right circ*mstances. If you live in an older home, it may be difficult to find replacements for aging locks. On the other hand, if you want to install a master key system, you’ll likely need the help of a pro to facilitate this whole-house system.

But if you need to change a standard lock in a modern home, you can likely make it a DIY project. You’ll need to remove and replace the deadbolt lock and hardware, ensuring that you test it before calling it a day.

Reasons You Should Change Your Locks

Considering whether to change your lock? Use this guide to determine whether it’s time to switch up your locks.

Changing the Look

Your home’s locks are a relatively easy feature to change if you want to upgrade their look. For example, if you are changing up the metal hardware throughout your home and want a more cohesive look.

Switching to a Keyless Lock System

If you’re ready to upgrade your home security system to include a modern keyless lock system, you’ll need to change your locks. Follow the lock system’s guidelines for DIY installation or hire a pro to tackle the task.

Upgrading to a Master Key System

Your locks are different brands and types, and you want them all to work with the same key. You’ll need to hire a local locksmith to set up a master key system in your home.

Using a Low-Quality or Older Lock

If your keys get stuck and lubricating the hardware doesn’t help, it’s time to upgrade to a new set. Major signs of keys in disrepair are rust spots or broken or chipped pieces. If you already have high-quality locks, opt for rekeying.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, you should change the locks as soon as you can after completing the purchase of a house. This is a matter of privacy and security, as you have no idea how many copies of the keys the previous owner made. You can change the locks yourself or hire a pro to replace or rekey the lock, which costs $50 to $100.

Should You Replace or Rekey Locks? (2024)

FAQs

Should You Replace or Rekey Locks? ›

If you're looking to get better security of your locks, changing them to new, higher security ones will be the way to go. Due to the extremely low price of the key pins in the locks, rekeying is almost always much cheaper than getting your locks changed.

Is it better to rekey or change locks? ›

In most scenarios, it makes more sense to rekey a lock instead of changing it outright. Rekeying is usually cheaper, and it still provides you with a renewed sense of security. If you move into a new home or if your key is lost or stolen, rekeying your lock will almost always suffice.

Should you replace locks on a new house? ›

When purchasing a new home, it's always a great idea to change the locks. You'll want to maintain key control over your home as a means of security. Key control means knowing exactly who has a key and how many there are in circulation.

Should you change your locks if you lose your keys? ›

A locksmith will recommend you change your door locks if you lose your keys as a security prevention. Changing your locks after losing your keys will stop anyone from accessing your home who does not have permission to.

How many times can you rekey a lock? ›

How many times can I re-key my lock? Unlimited amount of times. All you need is the Smarkey Security tool.

Will Ace hardware rekey locks? ›

Do you have too many keys to get into your house? For $12.00, you can bring in your Schlage, Kwikset, or Ace brand doorknob or deadbolt and our qualified staff will rekey it.

Should I key all my locks the same? ›

Advantages: The main advantages for having multiple door locks with one key (keying alike) are: Time Saver – Saves time without having to carry a set of keys around for every lock in the house or building. Save Money – You will only need to buy one key, even if you have 5 locks.

Should you change locks after closing? ›

Think about it: The keys you got at closing might not be the only ones in existence. “You never know who else had access to your home besides the seller, so it's best to change your locks for your personal safety,” says Wenzke.

Can I rekey my own locks? ›

When you rekey a lock by yourself, you will need to purchase a rekey kit that is specific to your brand of doorknob, lever, or deadbolt. Rekey kits allow you to rekey a lock to match existing keys in the kit. You will receive several keys (often between three and six keys), all identically cut.

How often should you change your house locks? ›

2.)

If your lock has been on your door more than a decade, it's definitely time to consider a replacement. The quality of the manufacturing does make a difference in longevity, but all in all, even the highest quality door lock is going to need replacing at about seven to 10 years old.

How long does it take to rekey a lock? ›

A rekey service can take between 10 and 40 minutes per lock. Rekeying only applied to keyed security locks, and not to privacy locks found on bathroom and bedroom doorknobs. New lock installation or replacement can take 30-60 minutes per lock, which is one reason that lock replacement is more expensive.

Are lost house keys covered by insurance? ›

Home insurance policies might offer protection for lost keys (or theft) but it's not always covered as standard. You would need to check the terms and conditions. If you have personal possessions insurance, which covers your belongings when you're out and about, keys are usually covered under.

Is losing a house key bad? ›

Sharing is caring! The odds of a burglar using a lost key to enter your home are very slim, but we still recommend replacing your locks after losing house keys.

What is the easiest lock to rekey? ›

Kwikset's SmartKey Security™ is designed to protect against these type of break-ins and keep your family safe. SmartKey Security™ also allows you to re-key the lock yourself in seconds, leaving lost or unreturned keys obsolete.

Can I get all my locks keyed the same? ›

You can head to your local hardware store and buy all key 'keyed alike' locks where all you need is one key and you can open each lock you buy. While this is going to be the most expensive option, if you don't know much about rekeying locks or making new keys, this is going to be the easiest solution for you.

Can you change a lock without changing the door knob? ›

Rekeying involves changing a lock cylinder's internal pins and springs to make the existing keys ineffective. It does not replace the entire lock or door hardware. There are scenarios where you can choose to rekey the locks rather than changing the whole hardware.

What is the cheapest way to change locks? ›

Yes, in almost all cases rekeying a lock is less expensive than replacing an old lock with a new one. Locks can be rekeyed multiple times (unless there is a fault with the lock or you want to change the style of your lock) making it a good low-cost option for rental or holiday properties.

How much does it cost to change the lock on a door? ›

The price range for this service is significant—from $50 to $300 overall, depending on how many locks you need changed and what types of locks you want. On a per-lock basis, the cost is between $40 and $100 for the lock itself plus another $15 to $40 per lock for labor.

Are keyed locks better than combination locks? ›

Since they don't contain dials, keyed locks offer a superior level of security when compared to combination locks. Unless a thief has the key, he or she won't be able to open it. Furthermore, keyed locks are better protected against shimming than combination locks.

What are the benefits of rekeying your locks? ›

The Advantages of Rekeying the Locks in Your Home
  • Fixes a security breach. ...
  • Customized locks. ...
  • No need for new hardware. ...
  • Allows for master key option. ...
  • Ability to change locks frequently. ...
  • Cost-effective. ...
  • Summing up.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duncan Muller

Last Updated:

Views: 6516

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duncan Muller

Birthday: 1997-01-13

Address: Apt. 505 914 Phillip Crossroad, O'Konborough, NV 62411

Phone: +8555305800947

Job: Construction Agent

Hobby: Shopping, Table tennis, Snowboarding, Rafting, Motor sports, Homebrewing, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Duncan Muller, I am a enchanting, good, gentle, modern, tasty, nice, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.