Bethan Moorcraft
·5 min read
How much money should you withdraw from your retirement savings each year to live out your golden years in comfort?
It’s a question weighs heavily on the minds of many Americans who are in or nearing retirement, and the answer can change depending on who you ask.
Don't miss
Commercial real estate has outperformed the S&P 500 over 25 years. Here's how to diversify your portfolio without the headache of being a landlord
Finish 2023 stronger than you started: 5 money moves you should make before the end of the year
The US dollar has lost 87% of its purchasing power since 1971 — invest in this stable asset before you lose your retirement fund
For years, financial planners and retirees have relied on the “4% rule” — coined in 1994 by financial adviser and author Bill Bengen — which states retirees should plan to withdraw 4% of their assets every year, increasing or decreasing that distribution annually based on inflation.
But in today’s challenging economic climate where Americans are tired of battling high inflation, interest rate hikes, market volatility and other challenges, the feasibility of the 4% rule has been called into question by some experts — including personal finance expert Suze Orman.
“It doesn't work anymore,” she told Moneywise in a May 16 interview. “I think it's very dangerous.”
Orman shared how much money she thinks you should withdraw each year in retirement — and it differs from the most recent figure given by Bengen himself.
Here’s what you need to know to figure out what withdrawal strategy works best for you.
Orman's alternative to the 4% rule
The money maven says she would “not be using the 4% rule on any level.”
Why? Because there’s no way to predict what’s going to happen once you are actually living the retired life, she explains.
Economic volatility could change the cost of living to the extent that 4% doesn’t meet your needs. There could be stock market swings that impact the value of your retirement portfolio, or further interest rate hikes that make any debt or loans that you hold more expensive.
You could face personal challenges like a health problem that requires a big pile or steady stream of cash. The uncertainties are endless, which is why Orman advises Americans to “take the least amount possible out of retirement accounts.”
Orman says the less money you withdraw each year, the “better off you are.”
Watch now: Full interview: Suze Orman and Devin Miller of SecureSave delve into why so many Americans aren't prepared for their next financial emergency
If you need a percentage target to hit, Orman suggests you only withdraw up to 3% of your nest egg each year.
At the same time, she encourages Americans to “work until at least 70 or longer, so that your assets have more of a chance to build up” and delay taking Social Security benefits until the age of 70 so that you receive the maximum monthly sum.
“Stop this: 'Oh, I'm going to retire at 60. I'm going to start claiming Social Security at 62,’” she said.
Read more: 'It's not taxed at all': Warren Buffett shares the 'best investment' you can make when battling inflation
The 4% rule creator says the opposite
Bengen based his retirement rule on several decades worth of statistics on retirement spending and stock and bond returns, which showed that retirees could reasonably expect their funds to last 30 years or longer if they withdrew about 4% from their nest eggs per year once they officially retire.
But he’s recently been compelled to revisit and update the rule given the current economic climate.
That’s because his original research only included two asset classes: Treasury bonds and large-cap stocks. When he added a third class, small-cap stocks, he said 4.5% would be a safe withdrawal rate.
But now, factoring in the impact of sky-high inflation, Bengen has argued that 4% might not cut it. In an appearance on the Bogleheads Live podcast in December 2022, Bengen revealed he’s upped his own withdrawal rate to 4.7% — quite different to Orman’s 3% target.
“My 4% rule was actually based upon a worst-case situation,” he said. “An investor who retired in October of 1968 who ran into just a terrible, perfect storm of bad stock market results and very high inflation, which forces withdrawals up every year.
“Are we in a similar period beginning with this year with very high inflation and potentially low stock market returns? Entering something even worse? I don't know, unfortunately. And we won't know for quite a few years.”
If the contrast between Bengen and Orman proves anything, it’s that your retirement withdrawal strategy is going to vary depending on your finances, assets and lifestyle.
Everyone’s situation is different. While a percentage rule might be a good starting point for planning, you may want to tweak it to suit your situation.
If you’re unsure what retirement strategy will work best, consider working with a financial adviser who can help you navigate your specific financial needs for the future.
With files from Sigrid Forberg
What to read next
Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now cash in on prime real estate — without the headache of being a landlord. Here's how
Worried about the economy? Here are the best shock-proof assets for your portfolio. (They’re all outside of the stock market.)
Rising prices are throwing off Americans' retirement plans — here’s how to get your savings back on track
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
