Taking sales proceeds and buying new stock typically doesn't save you from taxes.
The primary goal of all investors is to make money on their investments. Once you're fortunate enough to earn a profit on an investment, however, you also have to do what you can to keep as much as possible out of the hands of the tax man. With some investments, you can reinvest proceeds to avoid capital gains, but for stock owned in regular taxable accounts, no such provision applies, and you'll pay capital gains taxes according to how long you held your investment.
Special tax provisions don't apply to stock
The Internal Revenue Code is full of provisions that allow people to take proceeds from sales of property and reinvest it without having to recognize capital gain. The most popular is in the real-estate industry, where so-called "1031 like-kind exchanges" make it possible for owners to swap properties without any tax consequences. Similarly, in the life insurance industry, what are known as "1035 exchanges" allow policyholders to switch from one life insurance policy or annuity policy to another without having to pay capital gains tax on the paper profits from the policy being swapped out.
No such provisions apply to sales of stock in taxable accounts. Taxpayers have to recognize all of their capital gains. If they've owned the stock for a year or less, then they'll pay short-term capital gains tax at their ordinary income tax rate on the profit. If they've held the stock for longer than a year, then the lower long-term capital gains tax rates will apply.
How to avoid capital gains tax
The fact that there's no way out of paying tax on reinvested gains is one key reason why tax-favored retirement accounts are so popular. Within an IRA, 401(k), or other tax-favored retirement account, you can make sales of stock or other investments without any immediate tax consequences at all. You can then reinvest those proceeds in new stock. Only once you make withdrawals from your retirement account will tax issues come into play.
For your taxable account, though, your best defense against capital gains taxes is to be a long-term investor. You don't have to recognize capital gains on stock until you sell, so that gives those who invest in companies they're comfortable holding for years or even decades a leg up on short-term traders, who will end up paying a much higher tax burden.
Some argue that reinvesting gains from stock sales should be tax-free. Lacking major reform, though, investors should simply take steps to minimize the number of sales that force them to recognize such gains. Click here to compare brokers and choose the one that offers the most benefits for your investing style.
This article is part of The Motley Fool's Knowledge Center, which was created based on the collected wisdom of a fantastic community of investors. We'd love to hear your questions, thoughts, and opinions on the Knowledge Center in general or this page in particular. Your input will help us help the world invest, better! Email us at[emailprotected]. Thanks -- and Fool on!
FAQs
Is it taxable? Capital gains generated by funds held in a taxable account will result in taxable capital gains, even if you reinvest your capital gains back into the fund. Thus, it may be smart not to reinvest the capital gains in a taxable account so that you have the cash to pay the taxes due.
Can you avoid capital gains tax on stocks by reinvesting? ›
With some investments, you can reinvest proceeds to avoid capital gains, but for stock owned in regular taxable accounts, no such provision applies, and you'll pay capital gains taxes according to how long you held your investment.
What happens if I reinvest capital gains? ›
The taxpayers can minimize or avoid paying tax by reinvesting capital gains from residential house property under the Income Tax Act, 1961. The taxpayer can either reinvest the capital gains in bonds or in a residential property. The taxpayer needs to fulfil a few conditions in both of the options to gain tax benefits.
Why shouldn't you reinvest dividends? ›
You'll Limit Your Asset Diversification: Reinvesting your dividends in a company you already own shares of can result in an unbalanced portfolio. You Could Still Owe Taxes: It's important to note that dividends are taxed whether you take a cash payout or reinvest them.
Do you have to pay capital gains tax if you immediately reinvest? ›
The investor must pay capital gains taxes on distributions, whether they are taken as cash or reinvested in the fund. The taxes on distributions are due in that tax year unless the fund is part of a tax-deferred retirement account.
What is the 2 out of 5 year rule? ›
When selling a primary residence property, capital gains from the sale can be deducted from the seller's owed taxes if the seller has lived in the property themselves for at least 2 of the previous 5 years leading up to the sale. That is the 2-out-of-5-years rule, in short.
Is it smart to reinvest dividends and capital gains? ›
Dividend reinvestment is a great way for an investor to steadily grow wealth. Many brokers and companies enable investors to automate this process, allowing them to buy more shares (even fractional ones) with each payment and compounding their returns, which can add up over time.
How long to hold stock to avoid tax? ›
You may have to pay capital gains tax on stocks sold for a profit. Any profit you make from selling a stock is taxable at either 0%, 15% or 20% if you held the shares for more than a year. If you held the shares for a year or less, you'll be taxed at your ordinary tax rate.
What expenses can be claimed against capital gains tax? ›
You can deduct costs of buying, selling or improving your property from your gain. These include: estate agents' and solicitors' fees. costs of improvement works, for example for an extension - normal maintenance costs like decorating do not count.
When to stop reinvesting capital gains? ›
There are times when it makes better sense to take the cash instead of reinvesting dividends. These include when you are at or close to retirement and you need the money; when the stock or fund isn't performing well; when you want to diversify your portfolio; and when reinvesting unbalances your portfolio.
Dividends are taxable regardless of whether you take them in cash or reinvest them in the mutual fund that pays them out. You incur the tax liability in the year in which the dividends are reinvested.
How do I avoid paying taxes on reinvested dividends? ›
Reinvested dividends may be treated in different ways, however. Qualified dividends get taxed as capital gains, while non-qualified dividends get taxed as ordinary income. You can avoid paying taxes on reinvested dividends in the year you earn them by holding dividend stocks in a tax-deferred retirement plan.
What is a simple trick for avoiding capital gains tax on real estate investments? ›
A few options to legally avoid paying capital gains tax on investment property include buying your property with a retirement account, converting the property from an investment property to a primary residence, utilizing tax harvesting, and using Section 1031 of the IRS code for deferring taxes.
What is the capital gains tax for people over 65? ›
The capital gains tax over 65 is a tax that applies to taxable capital gains realized by individuals over the age of 65. The tax rate starts at 0% for long-term capital gains on assets held for more than one year and 15% for short-term capital gains on assets held for less than one year.
How long do you have to reinvest stock capital gains? ›
A: You can defer capital gains taxes by using a tax deferred exchange, which means that you reinvest the windfall from the sale into a replacement property. However, you need to act quickly. If you wait more than 180 days to reinvest, you will have to pay taxes on the proceeds.
How long do you need to hold a stock to avoid capital gains tax? ›
To correctly arrive at your net capital gain or loss, capital gains and losses are classified as long-term or short-term. Generally, if you hold the asset for more than one year before you dispose of it, your capital gain or loss is long-term. If you hold it one year or less, your capital gain or loss is short-term.
Do I have to report stocks if I reinvest? ›
You must complete Schedule B (Form 1040) and attach it to your Form 1040 or Form 1040-SR, if your ordinary dividends (in box 1a of Form 1099-DIV, Dividends and Distributions) and your reinvested dividends are more than $1,500.
